Radial vs Focused Shockwave Therapy: What Is the Difference?

Radial vs Focused Shockwave Therapy: What Is the Difference?

“Shockwave therapy” is offered for everything from heel pain to tennis elbow, and most people assume it is one treatment. It is two. Radial and focused shockwave work differently and suit different problems, though both are sold under the same word.

The difference matters because the right choice depends on how deep the painful structure sits.

How are they different?

A focused device produces a true acoustic shock wave that converges on a point at a set depth inside the tissue. The energy is concentrated at the target, and the skin gets far less. Focused devices use piezoelectric, electromagnetic or electrohydraulic technology.

A radial device works ballistically. A small projectile is fired against an applicator held on the skin, producing a pressure wave that spreads out from the point of contact. The wave is strongest at the surface and weakens as it travels deeper.

Everything else follows from where the energy is greatest. Strictly speaking, only the focused device produces a shock wave. The International Society for Medical Shockwave Treatment has noted that the radial output is more accurately called a pressure wave. Clinicians call both shockwave, which is where the confusion starts.

What is each used for?

Focused energy suits deeper or precisely located targets: a tendon, the point where a tendon attaches to bone, a joint, a ligament or bone itself.

Radial energy suits broad, superficial tissue such as tender muscle and fascia. Newer radial devices have a wider intensity range, and their makers say they reach deeper than older ones. That claim rests on laboratory testing. No clinical trials have yet compared the two in patients, so the two still shouldn’t be treated as equivalent.

Some structures sit in between. The middle part of the Achilles tendon lies close enough to the skin that a radial device is a fair choice, even though it is a tendon.

How does the evidence differ?

Both are thought to work through mechanotransduction, in which cells sense the acoustic energy and respond with chemical signals. The effects described across the research include better local blood flow, new blood vessel growth, calmer pain nerves and remodelling of tissue.

The evidence is uneven. Focused shockwave has substantial support in long-standing tendon problems, including pain where a tendon attaches to bone and calcific tendinopathy of the shoulder. Radial has good support in plantar heel pain. Trials comparing the two in the same condition are scarce, so claims that one is clearly better for a given problem usually run ahead of the data.

The evidence is consistent on one point. Either type works better combined with a progressive strengthening programme than on its own.

What should patients ask?

Anyone offered shockwave can ask three questions.

  1. Is it radial or focused? A vague answer is informative in itself.
  2. Why that one for this problem? The answer should mention where the painful structure sits.
  3. What rehabilitation goes with it? Shockwave without a loading programme is the weaker version of the treatment.

Many clinics own only one type of device. That is a fair limitation, and the clinic should say so.

What can’t either one do?

Neither regrows cartilage, reverses osteoarthritis or repairs a structural tear. Neither is a treatment for a fresh injury, because shockwave is used for persistent problems. Neither replaces working out what is causing the pain.

Side effects are generally minor and short-lived: local soreness, redness or bruising.

Which one is right?

For a deep tendon or a tendon attachment, focused is usually the better fit. For broad, superficial muscle pain, and for some heel pain, radial suits well. Each has its own page: radial shockwave and focused shockwave (ESWT). There is also a page on how shockwave fits into a staged treatment plan.

References

  • International Society for Medical Shockwave Treatment. ISMST Clinical Guidelines for Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy. 2024.
  • Schmitz C, Császár NBM, Milz S, et al. Efficacy and safety of extracorporeal shock wave therapy for orthopedic conditions: a systematic review on studies listed in the PEDro database. Br Med Bull. 2015;116:115-138.
  • Speed C. A systematic review of shockwave therapies in soft tissue conditions: focusing on the evidence. Br J Sports Med. 2014;48(21):1538-1542.
This article is general information only and is not a substitute for individual medical advice. It does not establish a doctor–patient relationship. Anyone with concerns about their own circumstances should see their GP or another qualified health practitioner.

Related Articles

Ready for a clearer plan for your back or musculoskeletal pain?

Book an assessment with Dr Joshua Hatch.

Your assessment focuses on understanding the likely source of your pain and the most appropriate non-surgical options for your diagnosis, with the aim of reducing pain and improving function.

You must have your own regular GP before booking. This service works alongside your GP for focused care. Booking requirements.

Book an appointment
Book an appointment with Back Pain Doctor